Insight

NEdge funds and the beta test of alpha

Kevin Gundle | Chief Executive Officer
22/02/2019
2 min read
Download Article

Most of 2018 was a continuation of 2017. In fact, it was also like most of the preceding nine years, characterised by solid equity market performance, low volatility and a world awash with liquidity. October, however, saw sentiment shift, markets move and increased debate across Aurum; a sea of red on the Bloomberg screens always generates interesting and animated conversation!

The reason we find market corrections so interesting is that they provide an opportunity, and the all-important data, to test the investment characteristics that we consider when performing analysis on hedge funds. While January has seen performance across the hedge fund industry improve, studying how funds perform in periods of market stress is invaluable to any investor.

Investors who allocate to hedge funds are seeking a few discrete outcomes – namely, performance, capital preservation and low correlation to traditional asset classes. The Aurum funds strive to deliver these three outcomes. Our view is that a portfolio that has low correlation to traditional asset classes is more likely to achieve performance and capital preservation. For portfolios that have performance as their primary objective, the siren song of the market can be very seductive – and unfortunately, for many hedge funds and investors, it was.

The challenge facing hedge fund investors today is identifying whether the real return that they are seeking is likely to be delivered. Unfortunately, many will be disappointed. Our analysis clearly shows that the majority of funds that describe themselves as hedge funds have not delivered the desired three outcomes of performance, capital preservation and low correlation to traditional asset classes.

A worryingly large proportion of the $3 trillion of hedge funds that Aurum tracks fall into a category that we refer to as ‘NEdge funds’, i.e. not exactly hedge funds. These NEdge funds may be structured in the same way as hedge funds, but have an investment style that is unlikely to reliably meet investor expectations of low correlation, performance and capital preservation.

To find out which funds fell into the hedge fund bucket versus the NEdge fund bucket we employed a simple test with the objective of answering a simple question – how did the funds fare across 2018, and during the fourth quarter, 2018’s most challenging period for risk assets, in particular? Drilling down further, how did hedge funds perform in December, a month that saw most hedge fund indices report negative returns across the board? We called this exercise the Beta Test of Alpha.

Of the ~4,000 funds that reported their returns to the end of December 2018, only 37% were positive in 2018. Furthermore, a mere 23% were positive in Q4 2018; 24% were positive in October; 44% were positive in November and 31% were positive in December. It seems that there are a lot of NEdge funds out there. We could do a lot more slicing and dicing, but these results led us to the conclusion that most funds failed the Beta Test of Alpha.

Identifying good hedge fund managers is like finding needles in haystacks. As the hedge fund industry has developed into a huge field of haystacks, the number of needles simply hasn’t kept up. It is only when there is a fire in the field, that the needles can be found.

A key characteristic of a hedge fund should be the ability to endure the inflection points as new market cycles develop. We may be at such a point, with global debt nearing record levels*, central bank balance sheets shrinking and geopolitical risks continuing. The next decade will be different to the last. Agility, focus and ability will be important qualities for any investment manager. And, when it comes to hedge funds, a singular focus on delivering the three outcomes should be enough to prevent their relegation to the NEdge category and failure in the next Beta Test of Alpha, when it comes.

Nedge-Funds

You may also like

Monthly hedge fund performance review – May 2022

20/06/2022

Hedge fund performance was generally negative in May, with wider dispersion than in April. Macro was the only master strategy with positive returns. Strategies…

Multi-strategy deep dive – Apr 22

31/05/2022

Multi-strategy funds posted 12 consecutive months of positive returns during a period that provided a number of significant challenges across the hedge…

Is performance or asset gathering driving growth in hedge fund industry assets?

23/05/2022

In the wake of recent market volatility, even more investors are seeking downside protection from hedge funds, resulting in large inflows into the hedge…

Monthly hedge fund performance review – April 2022

19/05/2022

Hedge fund performance was mixed in April with slightly wider dispersion than in March. Strategies with a higher beta to equities remained weaker than…

Aurum’s quarterly review – Q1 2022

26/04/2022

All of Aurum’s managed funds and bespoke accounts delivered positive returns in the first quarter of 2022. Performance for Aurum’s commingled fund…

Monthly hedge fund performance review – March 2022

20/04/2022

Hedge fund performance was generally positive in March; dispersion was slightly wider than in February. Strategies with a higher beta to equities remained…

Three top tips for designing an employee volunteering programme

08/04/2022

Emily Forsyth-Davies, Head of ESG, Aurum Research Limited, has recently revamped the Aurum Group’s UK employee volunteering offering. These are her three…

Monthly hedge fund performance review – February 2022

22/03/2022

Hedge fund performance was mixed in February; dispersion was tighter and losses were less severe than in January. Strategies with a higher beta to equities…

Event deep dive – Jan 22

07/03/2022

Event driven funds generated an average return of +9.1% in the 12 months to January 2022. AUM has grown by $28.5bn, 76% of this growth was driven by performance….

Monthly hedge fund performance review – January 2022

21/02/2022

Most hedge fund strategies finished 2021 with positive performance in December, with slightly tighter dispersion than was observed in November. Strategies…

Does structure matter? Hedge funds v Alternative UCITS

15/02/2022

Since their inception in 2007, alternative UCITS, a.k.a. alt UCITS, liquid alternatives, or UCITS hedge funds have been popular with investors. Over the…

Aurum’s quarterly review – Q4 2021

27/01/2022

All of Aurum’s managed funds and bespoke accounts delivered positive returns in the fourth quarter of 2021. Performance for Aurum’s commingled funds…